Thursday, September 16, 2021

Gilded Age Good Taste in Dress

“Good taste is indispensable in dress, but that, united to neatness, is all that is necessary—that is the fabled Cetus of Venus which gave beauty to its wearer.”

Mrs. Manners, the highest authority we can possibly quote in such matters, has the following hints to girls, which we can not deny ourselves the pleasure of copying, though they may seem, in part, a repetition of remarks already made: 

“Good taste is indispensable in dress, but that, united to neatness, is all that is necessary—that is the fabled cestus of Venus which gave beauty to its wearer. Good taste involves suitable fabrics—a neat and becoming ‘fitting’ to her figure—colors suited to her complexion, and a simple and unaffected manner of wearing one's clothes. A worsted dress in a warm day, or a white one in a cold day, or a light, thin one in a windy day, are all in bad taste. Very fine or very delicate dresses worn in the street, or very highly ornamented clothes worn to church or to shop in, are in bad taste. Very long dresses worn in muddy or dusty weather, even if long dresses are the fashion, are still in bad taste. 

“Deep and bright-colored gloves are always in bad taste; very few persons are careful enough in selecting gloves. Light shoes and dark dresses, white stockings and dark dresses, dark stockings and light dresses, are not indicative of good taste. A girl with neatly and properly dressed feet, with neat, well-fitting gloves, smoothly arranged hair, and a clean, well-made dress, who walks well, and speaks well, and, above all, acts politely and kindly, is a lady, and no wealth is required here. Fine clothes and fine airs are abashed before such propriety and good taste. Thus the poorest may be so attired as to appear as lady-like as the wealthiest; nothing is more vulgar than the idea that money makes a lady, or that fine clothes can do it.”– 
Samuel R. Wells's How to Behave: The Pocket Manual of Good Manners and Model Behavior, 1870


🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber of The RSVP Institute of Etiquette, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Wednesday, September 15, 2021

Etiquette of a Gilded Age French Table

A carafe is placed between each place: on one side a carafe of water, on the other, a carafe of table wine. Before each place are four glasses: a water glass, a Bordeaux glass, a Madeira glass and a Champagne glass. They can be placed a straight line or in a square, whichever pleases you more. Put the tallest first.


The illustration (above) gives an approximate disposition for a table set for 20 places at the moment the guests arrive.

A carafe is placed between each place: on one side a carafe of water, on the other, a carafe of table wine. Before each place are four glasses: a water glass, a Bordeaux glass, a Madeira glass and a Champagne glass. They can be placed a straight line or in a square, whichever pleases you more. Put the tallest first.

Small double salts are distributed so that each guest has one within reach.

At n°1, in the centre and at either end of the table, baskets of flowers.

At one of the n°2, placed in turn, the fish, tête de veau en tortue, etc., which will be replaced by a roast, and later, at dessert by a compote, or a raised fruit plate; at the other n°2 a pâté or a ham or display of shells which is not touched during the first service and which is replaced, at dessert, also by a compote, or a raised fruit plate.

At nº3, the entrées, - fish, red meat, poultry, game, replaced by the entremets, - 2 egg or vegetable entremets and to be 2 sweet entremets, - and at dessert by the compotes or raised fruit plates.

At n°4, fruit compotes.

At nº5, compotes or plates with petits fours or confectionery.

At n°6, sugar bowls, one for granulated sugar, the other for sugar cubes.

At n°7, crystal compotes for jams, fruit conserves or fruits in eau-de-vie; and later the cheeses beneath their crystal covers.

At nº8, dessert plates, walnuts, almonds, dried figs, raisins, chestnuts, etc.

At n°9, lamps.

At nºs 10, candlesticks.

At n°11, eight hors-d'œuvres.

If one owns dish warmers they are to be placed beneath the dishes which should be eaten hot. They should also be placed under other plates for the sake of symmetry; but these should not be lit.


Émile Dumont 'La Bonne Cuisine française', Paris, 1873


Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Tuesday, September 14, 2021

1880’s French Tables and Dining

During the course of the meal, the servants should be attentive that nothing is missing from the table; they should always be ready to offer bread, water or wine or any other complement that the guests might desire. They should change the plates for each course; as for the knife and fork, they too, should be changed for each course, if possible. In any event, they must be replaced after the fish course. It is absolutely necessary.
⚜
 ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ ⚜ 
In French gastronomy, cuisine bourgeoise is the home cooking of affluent city dwellers, as distinguished from elaborate restaurant cooking, haute cuisine, and from the cooking of the regions, the peasantry, and the urban poor. The cuisine bourgeoise has been documented since the 17th century: Nicolas de Bonnefons, Le Jardinier françois and Les delices de la campagne; François Menon, Cuisinière bourgeoise; and Louis Eustache Audot, Cuisinière de la campagne et de la ville.


French Cuisine Bourgeoise Table Service of 1888


The dining room, the table. – 
The day of the dinner, the dining room should be appropriately readied early in the day. In winter, it should be heated well before the meal begins but the temperature should not exceed 15° C (or 59° F). In the evening, the windows should be closed and the lamps or chandeliers lit. The floor should be covered with a carpet, at least where the guests are seated.

In summer these precautions are unnecessary as it is preferable to dine in an airy location.

The day of the dinner, the table must be covered in advance. The tablecloth must be very large and spotlessly white; the central part of it, covered by one or several table linens. 

The place settings of each guest should be arranged symmetrically, a small bread roll placed beneath the folds of each white napkin which is folded simply. 

Each place setting should have a and spoon to the right, a fork to the left. 

Glasses, arranged by height, are placed to the right and slightly above the table setting in a diagonal line.

For formal, black-tie dinners, where guest are numerous, pitchers of water and table wine are placed between each guest so that water and wine is readily accessible; but at informal dinners of 6 to 8 people, for example, 2 jugs of water and 2 carafes of table wine should be sufficient.

How the guests should be seated. – 
At a prestigious dinner, the mistress of the house is seated at the centre of one end of the table, the master of the house at the other, so that they face each other across the length of the table.

At formal dinners, the name of each guest appears on a placecard at each set ting. At informal dinners, it is the mistress of the house who decides where each guest should sit.

For men, the place of honor is at the right side of the mistress of the house; for ladies, it is at the right side of the master of the house. The left side of each is also valued but is of less importantance. Following these indications, the mistress of the house should be seated between two men and the master of the house between two women. 

After these four places of privilege have been designated, the other guests may take their place, assuring as much as possible that each lady is seated in between two men.

The meal.–
During the meal, the host and the mistress of the house should assure above all the punctuality of the service; but without affectation or noise. Neither one nor the other should leave their seat under any pretext. All must be organized so that their intervention is not necessary. This rule applies as well to the host or hostess during the meal. 

At informal dinners where the head of the family is carving, a carving knife and fork at the side of his place setting.

As soon as the guests are seated, the soup is served in soup plates; but neither the soup nor the soup plates should be on the table; they are in-waiting on the sideboard. They should only be presented to the guests when they are filled or refilled. 

Each dinner course is either presented to the guests or placed in front of the head of the family so that he may distribute them. 

If the courses are individual or easy to serve, they are presented; if not, they are placed on the table to be distributed or carved. 

At informal dinners, where fine wines are not in abundance, full glasses are not served. It is the responsability of the host to serve his guests and then circulate the bottles; but the servants should be careful that each glass is filled with the appropriate wine.

During the course of the meal, the servants should be attentive that nothing is missing from the table; they should always be ready to offer bread, water or wine or any other complement that the guests might desire.

They should change the plates for each course; as for the knife and fork, they too, should be changed for each course, if possible. In any event, they must be replaced after the fish course. It is absolutely necessary.

The service should be accomplished in silence, without hurrying, without raised voices.

When a servant offers something to a guest, whether it be a knife, glass or any other object, it should de presented on a tray and not by hand. The bread should be offered from the bread basket. If the servant offers wine to the guests, he should name each wine he offers or pours.

For dinners served ‘plat à plat’, the service should not abide any interruption, the courses follow one after the other until the entremets; at which point, the servants take away the plates, the place settings, the salt cellars, the bread and all available bottles; the table is then brushed of crumbs.

They give the guests, plates, dessert spoons and knives. The dessert is then placed on the table, in a planned and studied symmetrical order. As soon as the guests have begun the dessert, it is suggested that the servants leave the guests to themselves. If needed, the mistress of the house can summon them.

Coffee is served after the dessert. At formal dinners, coffee is never served on the same table as the meal, but for informal meals, it is often preferred, following the dessert.

In this case, the table should again be readied, that is, plates and knives taken away and the table brushed again of crumbs.

The dessert. – 
The dinner's dessert should be of particuler interest to the mistress of the house, as it is likely to be of great importance to a number of her guests.

The dessert consists of cheese, fresh or dry fruits, fruits-in-liqueur, jellies or jams, petits fours, biscuits, macaroons, sweetmeats and finally, ice-cream.

The fruit, cheese, petit fours or biscuits are arranged on plates or compotes; the jams are served in their original jars or in crystal jam pots; the same is true of fruits-in-liqueur. The sweetmeats are arranged on a plate or on porcelain or metal stands.

Very often, a cleverly arranged basket of fruit occupies the centre of the table. When the dessert arrives it is displayed around this centrepiece. The ice-creams are then presented.

The wines. – 
Regardless of the importance of the dinner, carafes of red and white table wine must always be on the table. As for the quantity of the wine, it is in keeping with the importance of the dinner. 

In any event, in a bourgeoise home, this aspect of the service is of particular interest to the host. Thanks to his diligence, the wines are served not only with the specific courses for which they are destined, but also at the optimal temperature which will bring out their best qualities.

If the red wines have formed a residue, they should be decanted, that is, poured into another decanter without agitating the residue at the bottom of the bottle. But, white wine is not decanted; only those being clear and limpid are to be served. 

As for the ideal serving temperature of each wine, it varies according to the nature of the wine. In general, all white wine should be served cooled, even in ice. 

Bordeaux wines should be served at 15° C  (or 59° F), but that does not mean they should be warmed artificially; taking them from the cellar 4 to 5 hours before serving should suffice, and resting them in the dining room or even in the kitchen until the wine has attained the desired temperature. 

Burgundy wines should be drunk more or less fresh; according to the season.

In summer, they are kept cooled, in winter, they are served at 7 to 8° C; a little less warm than Bordeaux wines.

Champagne should be well-chilled at all times, that is to say iced; a wine of this sort that is not chilled is never pleasant and cannot be appreciated. Dessert liqueurs should always be served cooled.

The order of serving wines. –
After the soup, guests are given a glass of Madeira or Marsala. After the fish and oysters, white wine is served: Chablis, Sauterne, Moselle, etc.

With meat, one serves what is called ‘les grands ordinaires’: Burgundy or Bordeaux; but Burgundy is preferable. Bordeaux is better for entrées and large roasts¹; but with roasts, nothing prevents one from serving a Burgundy wine de grand cru, and with vegetables, a fine Bordeaux. After the vegetables and until dessert, Champagne is served.

(1) There are many people who think that one cannot drink Bordeaux after Burgundy. As concerns wine tasting, I would agree with them; but as one eats different dishes at the table, the bouquet of the wine one has just drunk does not stay in the mouth to the extent that it would ruin the bouquet of the wine to follow.

Coffee. – 
If coffee is served at the same table as the meal, it is usually the mistress of the house who pours and serves it to the guests, at the same time as various liqueurs but that is only possible at informal dinners with a limited numbers of guests.



From Urbain Dubois Nouvelle Cuisine Bourgeoise, Paris, 1888

Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Monday, September 13, 2021

Etiquette: Solver of Sticky Social Dilemmas

Drinking can pose problems if you are a hostess, you must refuse to serve more liquor to an inebriated guest, Post said. “You are then responsible for seeing that a drunken guest arrives home safely by asking a good friend to escort this guest home,” Post said, adding that you also might drive the guest home yourself, or call and pay for a cab. – From “Emily Post On Etiquette” 
Image from the Etiquipedia© personal library



Etiquette was invented to solve those sticky social dilemmas… 


Life is full of sticky social situations but there's no need to become unglued, because etiquette was invented to solve these problems. The traditional way to solve social dilemmas has been to ask Emily Post, who first published her book “Etiquette” in 1922. In the current issue of Redbook, Elizabeth Post, a granddaughter of the original Emily, answers some of today’s etiquette quandaries in an excerpt from her book, “Emily Post On Etiquette.” 

  • Proper party manners often pose problems. What happens, for instance, if you are invited to a cocktail party the same weekend a cousin is visiting. Can you ask your hostess if your cousin may attend? “No. Decline the invitation and explain your reason to the hostess,” Post advised. “She then has the option to say, ‘I'm sorry you can’t come, we’ll miss you,’ or, if she feels your cousin’s presence won’t make a difference in her planning, she may say, ‘Do bring him. I’d love to meet your cousin.”’
  • Hostesses may have a problem dealing with the guest whose babysitter has defected and asks to bring her baby to an adults-only cocktail party. “An adults-only party is just that, and you need not feel you are being rude by telling your guest you would love for her to come, but the party is for adults and you do not have accommodations for an infant,” Post wrote. 
  • Then there’s the dinner at which you are offered a dish you don’t like. Among friends. Post said, you can just say, “No, thank you.” Otherwise it is good manners to take and eat at least a little of every dish offered, except in cases of allergy or special diet. 
  • Smokers sometimes are uncertain about when and where they can light up. “If a smoker is visiting a house for the first time, or is with people he or she doesn’t know well, or is in close quarters with friends, the smoker should always ask, ‘Do you mind if I smoke?’ If someone does mind, don’t smoke,” Post said. 
  • Drinking can pose problems if you are a hostess, you must refuse to serve more liquor to an inebriated guest. Post said. “You are then responsible for seeing that a drunken guest arrives home safely by asking a good friend to escort this guest home,” Post said, adding that you also might drive the guest home yourself, or call and pay for a cab. 
  • If you are the one who drinks too much at a party and are insulting, rude or disruptive, you must call and apologize. If you simply left the party early, without embarrassing yourself or anyone else, you need apologize only for early departure. 
  • It’s a wise guest who knows when to call it a night “Try to be sensitive to, and aware of, the people around you,” Post wrote “Most hostesses are reluctant to speed the departure of guests, even when they are ready to end a party.” Look for signs of tiredness, then make your move to break up the party. But remember, etiquette dictates you not eat and run. You should remain at least one hour after dinner. 
  • For the hostess who wants to let the guests know it’s time to go home, Post advises closing the bar, offering a last nightcap and making a show of putting the liquor away. A hostess may also yawn and look at her watch. – AP Features, 1988


Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia 

Sunday, September 12, 2021

Correspondence Ink Etiquette

The Romans used both black and red ink, because we find Pompeian inkstands with double receptacles. Nero, that uncommon brute, when he composed verses, wrote his lines in gold. – Depiction of Nero
-Photo source, Pinterest


Occasionally, the schoolboy, meddling with the sacredness of his father's writing table, finds the bottle of red ink, and indites a letter in brilliant carmine. Then his elders explain to him what a horrible crime he has perpetrated. The next unconservative urchin who does that may nonplus his parents by informing them that the Roman Emperors who were deities disdained commonplace black ink, and signed only in red. The Romans used both black and red ink, because we find Pompeian inkstands with double receptacles. Nero, that uncommon brute, when he composed verses, wrote his lines in gold.– The New York Times, 1897


Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Saturday, September 11, 2021

Dining Etiquette and the French Family

Have dinner together! Dining communally with other family members has benefits. – “France is one of the last places to resist the solitude that modern society has come to create. As a rule the French continue to eat their meals at the table and at regular times. On average an hour is dedicated to the preparation of these home-cooked meals. More than any other nation, the French continue to dine among friends, either in their homes or at restaurants, if finances allow. This preservation of habits has most benefited their health. There is less obesity than in any other European country, and the rate of heart disease is the lowest in the western world.” – Jacques Attali, 2007

Dînons ensemble! 
The French must continue to eat their meals together at the table, the ultimate place for communal living.


A study published on the 10th of May by INSEE, (l'Institut national de la statistique et des études économiques), which went relatively unnoticed, revealed that the French are the last people in the western world who continue to regularly eat their meals at the table as a family. Elsewhere, the traditional meal has long since disappeared. In the United States, Germany, Great Britain and Japan, people eat lunch and dinner separately following the confines of their daily schedule. The more people are qualified, the younger they are, the later they dine. However, we are not necessarily speaking of actual meals: everybody snacks, alone, at all times of the day and evening.


France is one of the last places to resist the solitude that modern society has come to create. As a rule the French continue to eat their meals at the table and at regular times. On average an hour is dedicated to the preparation of these home-cooked meals. More than any other nation, the French continue to dine among friends, either in their homes or at restaurants, if finances allow. This preservation of habits has most benefited their health. There is less obesity than in any other European country, and the rate of heart disease is the lowest in the western world.


Even in France, dining collectively at the table, this ultimate expression of communal life, is often only an illusion. During the meal the women serve and clear away the food, while the men watch television. After the meal, household chores remain the work of women, whereas the men spend the bulk of the evening in front of the small screen. In France as elsewhere, the duration of meals becomes shorter as conversation becomes rarer.


In all civilizations, the essence of social construction occurs through attitudes towards food, as meals provide one of the main opportunities for sharing and communication. In modern French society, nothing will be more important than to protect these rare moments; to give meaning to those who have lost it and to create conditions for equality of the sexes with consideration of the tasks required. The length and manner of the meals will have to be contemplated as political, in the best sense of the word.


 By Jacques Attali,
Professor, writer, governmental advisor, 2007, Preface for “French Silver Cutlery of the XIXth Century”

Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Friday, September 10, 2021

Gilded Age Champagne Etiquette

“What!” said he, “drink a champagne of 1880. Why, it is too absurd!” I told him it was that or nothing, for we were far behind them in England, drinking new champagnes and having no old ones. The idea is prevalent that champagne will not keep in this climate. After a few years, one will always order his supply from abroad yearly, keeping his champagne at his London wine merchant’s or at the vineyard.

Brut Champagne – Another Revolution in treatment of this Wine – It must be Old to be good –‘74 Champagne worth $8 a bottle in Paris– How to frappé Champagne


THE fashionable world here have accepted the Brût champagne, and avoid all other kinds; ladies even more than men. But another revolution is to occur in this country in the next five years in the treat ment of this wine. We will soon follow the example of our English brethren and never drink it until it is from eight to ten years old.

A year or two ago one the most fashionable men in London asked me to assist him in ordering a dinner at Delmonico's. When we came to ordering the wines, he exclaimed against the champagne. “What!” said he, “drink a champagne of 1880. Why, it is too absurd!” I told him it was that or nothing, for we were far behind them in England, drinking new champagnes and having no old ones.

The idea is prevalent that champagne will not keep in this climate. After a few years, one will always order his supply from abroad yearly, keeping his champagne at his London wine merchant’s or at the vineyard. To evidence the improvement in champagne by age, I can only cite that the champagne of 1874 has sold in London at auction for $7 a bottle, and now in Paris and London you pay $8 a bottle for a '74 wine at a restaurant, and $6 for an 1880 wine; at the vineyard itself $45 a dozen, and hard to obtain at this price. If you once drink one of these old champagnes you will never again drink a fresh wine. In England, they now drink no Madeira; it is never served. At their dinners they pride themselves on giving 1874 champagne. If they can give this wine, with a Golden Sherry and a fine glass of Port, they are satisfied.

It will be well to remember that champagnes are now known to connoisseurs by their vintage. Wines of some vintages do not keep at all. In keeping champagnes, keep only, or order kept for you, the champagnes of the best vintages. Of course, there is much risk in keeping any champagne; but what all strive for, is to possess something that no one else has; that is not purchasable, I mean, in any quantity, and this now is 1874 champagne.

To properly frappé champagne, put in the pail small pieces of ice, then a layer of rock salt, alternating these layers until the tub is full. Put the bottle in the tub; be careful to keep the neck of the bottle free from the ice, for the quantity of wine in the neck of the bottle being small, it would be acted upon by the ice first. If possible, turn the bottle every five minutes. In twenty-five minutes from the time it is put in the tub, it should be in perfect condition, and should be served immediately. What I mean by perfect condition is, that when the wine is poured from the bottle, it should contain little flakes of ice; that is a real frappé. — From “Society As I Have Found It” by Ward McAllister


Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Thursday, September 9, 2021

An Interview with Nancy Hoogenboom

If you are familiar with the @daily.etiquette Instagram feed, then you’ve probably seen Nancy Hoogenboom’s colorful and fun posts, filled with fascinators, flowers and fun! Nancy was one of our two “Blue Ribbon” winners from the Etiquette Community for our 1st Annual Etiquipedia Place Setting Competition. 
🍽 🍽 🍽 🍽 
Nancy Hoogenboom is the founder and CEO of Daily Etiquette, a Southern California School of Etiquette and Protocol. In addition to being a certified etiquette trainer, she is a speaker, author, consultant, and coach. According to her website, “Nancy makes etiquette relevant for today’s society in social media, personal interaction, and social and professional settings. By bringing the basics of etiquette into the day to day activities of our lives, Nancy is able to show new insights in communication with those in our lives.”
Congratulations, Nancy!

Nancy’s place setting is ‘all dressed up and ready to celebrate’ something, by all appearances and the colors used in many of the elements.

As Nancy did not provide a menu for us, we had to guess what she might be serving at this festive place setting. Nancy’s setting looks as if it jumped off the pages of a website or holiday catalog, with the metallic gold welcoming the guest with a festive, visual splash. This could be done with glossy silver, copper, brass or bronze elements and still retain the celebratory feeling this evokes (If another element were to be used, I would recommend an ivory, or the palest grey, table cloth, place mat or runner when using silver or bronze elements – and more of a bright white for copper or brass.) The “Thankful” written across the bread plate makes me immediately think of the Autumn and Winter holiday season. 

If it is for a holiday dinner, it is done very subtly, without the use of any whimsical holiday decor or tchotchkes. The kumquats in the water are a subtle nod to winter months and blend seamlessly with the color scheme. That is not easy, as those decorative items, if poorly chosen, can lessen the overall look of one’s holiday table. If you’re having just family and good friends, all of those items you’ve saved over the years –the ones that your children or grandchildren made in school– can be wonderful and make your table homey, as well as attractive. If you’re going for a much more formal and upscale look, leave the kids’ art projects off of the dining table.
This setting has a teaspoon, which is automatically considered superfluous, unless there is a course which would require a teaspoon. However, a bowl is the first dish that will be used. Not being a soup spoon, in any size or shape, it would have to be for some sort of food that would require a large round bowl, but not a spoon with a large round bowl.
A few etiquette notes on Nancy’s setting: 
Specificity on what will be served, and when, is always helpful when imagining how well a place setting suits a menu. This setting has a teaspoon, which is automatically considered superfluous, unless there is a course which would require a teaspoon. However, a bowl is the first dish that will be used. Not being a soup spoon, in any size or shape, it would have to be for some sort of food that would require a large round bowl, but not a spoon with a large round bowl. It’s possible her set did not have the proper spoon for the bowl or vice versa, or the dish requires the teaspoon, as a helper, for the salad-sized fork. I just had to guess. Which brings me to the bowl…

Regular readers of mine of the @Etiquipedia Instagram feed, know that one of my biggest pet peeves is a dish or utensil, of any kind, placed atop the napkin. Dishes or utensils do not belong atop napkins for the simple reason that one’s guests should be able to sit, lift their napkins, place them in their laps and begin dining. They should not have to sit, lift up whatever sits atop the napkins with one hand, then hold them or figure out where to place them, while with the other hand, remove their napkins and try to gracefully lay them across their laps, all before beginning to dine. Guests should never have to re-lay a table, but that’s what they’re forced to do when napkins are “artistically” placed beneath flatware and dishes. 
I forgave this faux pas, as 1.We had no menu. 2.We were given no “story” regarding how this meal would be served. And 3.I have seen it work before; once at a holiday dinner with a hearty stew in a bowl served buffet/style for the first course only, while guests watched a holiday lights boat show prior to the seated dinner, and again at a buffet bridal luncheon, when the crudités / amuse bouche plates were atop the napkins. People milled around chatting, partaking of the first course, while napkins were moved to the chairs, prior to everyone being seated for the luncheon. 
Again, those were the only two times I can remember that it worked. Most times, this does not work and many people, especially in the case of plates atop napkins, wind up not removing the napkins, and resort to just wiping their fingers on these napkins sticking out from underneath plates or utensils, which tend to resemble untucked shirts.

The fabric of the napkin is not technically proper for a dinner napkin, though I cannot be certain just by seeing it as it sits under the bowl. It may be the gold fabric on one side and a damask on the reverse. An argument can also be made though, for the need for such a napkin, adding to the festive look of a holiday table – and we have seen designers use lamé in competitive settings of the early 1900’s.

The napkin is not technically proper for a dinner napkin, though I cannot be certain just by seeing it as it sits under the bowl. Could it be gold fabric on one side and a damask on the reverse?

I was pleased to see the butter spreader placed on the “bread plate” correctly. Too many hosts and hostesses have taken to placing these spreaders in a vertical manner (à la caterers or cruise lines), which is incorrect. Historically, any knife should face toward the diner or his / her plate. Blades of knives should never point toward anyone else at the table. 
I overlooked the fact that the bread plate is more of a salad size. In fact, I didn’t even notice that the plate was too big until I saw the photo from a different angle. After judging, I was shown the settings with who had created them in the photos. That was when the size of the plate for bread really jumped out at me. It’s a tad smaller than the dinner plate. It’s funny, but little details like this separate the beautiful, correct and functional place settings from the rare, perfect place settings.

An optical illusion… Placemats are not meant to go atop tablecloths or table runners. The fact that this placemat looks more like a decorative trivet, works in its favor and it shows lots of the table covering. That makes this a natural fit for the table. It actually helps the table look sparse and uncluttered.  

Other little details which are not technically correct but allowable in my eyes? 

  • The salt and pepper are too close to the glassware for my comfort, however the table elements are sparse enough that they dont seem too out of place. Ideally they should be somewhere in the upper to mid-left third of the place setting. (Directly to the right of the bread plate, above the left rim of the dinner plate or in the mid point, horizontally and vertically from the next place setting to the left, to be shared with the person sitting next to you.)

  • This table appears to have a lot of room though, and it’s a visual trick… an optical illusion… that is giving this a roomier appearance. The “placemat” is part of this illusion. Placemats are not meant to go atop tablecloths or table runners. The fact that this placemat looks more like a decorative trivet, works in its favor and it shows lots of the table covering. That makes this a natural fit for the table. It actually helps the table look sparse and uncluttered. 

  • There are only two glasses at the place setting, adding to an uncluttered look. Again, not having a menu leaves me to guess that the glasses are correct. I have to give the benefit of doubt. 

  •  And lastly, the candle wicks have not been burnt. If you are in the category of numerous armchair judges who are horrified at the untouched wicks, it has been a good hundred and fifty years since it was considered a social crime to show off your wealth by the gauche display of unburnt wicks on candles in one’s homes. I have never marked points off for non-burnt wicks. That being said, I think wicks which have been burnt down a bit, giving the candles just a slight dip and hint of melted wax on top, have a very pleasing aesthetic look to them. They just look a bit nicer when burnt, but are no longer an etiquette issue if not.


4 Questions for Nancy

1. Have you always enjoyed a properly set table? Or, if not, was table setting something you learned to enjoy through your social life and/or business, later on in life?
I have always enjoyed a creative place setting since I can remember, the laughter that filled the room as we sat and enjoyed friendship and food around the table. I have fond memories of my mom having the most elegant tea parties for families and friends as we sat and enjoyed savory tea sandwiches, scones with cream and jam, fruit tarts, mini-cakes and delightful conversations.

As I began to educate myself about etiquette and modern manners, the reason’s behind “The Art of The Place Setting” was extremely interesting and intriguing. As a Certified Etiquette and Modern Manners Trainer and Coach, I now have the pleasure to teach others the beautiful “Art of The Table Settings.”

2. How did you choose the various elements you used in your setting and why?
I choose the various elements for my table setting form our home. I enjoy using items I have already in my home and garden, from crystal wine glasses and china we were given as wedding gifts 39 years ago to modern place table setting pieces including greenery and flowers from our garden. I enjoy mixing vintage and modern pieces to make a unique and inviting table setting.

3. How, if at all, did Covid related social restrictions affect your choice of setting? Were you ready to celebrate? Feeling in the mood to do something different? Etc…
The pandemic has been a challenge in many ways, as far as the meal, finding unique food items at our local stores was not as assessable. I was inspired by a wedding menu we attended and made it my own.

4. Do you plan on entering again next year?
I’m excited for the next International Place Setting Competition, I already have exciting ideas for what I am planning. Such a joy to see all the talented place settings entered, I’m inspired seeing and reading about each participant’s story.

Thank you Maura Graber of etiquipedia.blogspot.com @Etiquipedia and Elizabeth Soos, professor at the Auersmont School of Etiquette in Australia @auersmont_schooofetiquette for hosting The First Annual Etiquipedia International Place Setting Competition. I was honored to participate and delighted to see all the incredible ancient to modern place settings.

Thank you again for Maura and Elizabeth, this has been delightful competition!

Elizabeth Soos and I would both like to congratulate Nancy on her wonderfully festive Blue Ribbon winning place setting. We are looking forward to see what Nancy comes up with for next year’s competition, without the constraints that Covid-19 brought us!


Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia