Friday, December 16, 2022

Wedding Invitation Etiquette

 

What Readers Ask: “I am to be married the end of this month and my mother says that, as a matter of war time economy, she thinks we can get along without engraved invitations. Still, I am to be married in church and am to have about fifty guests all of whom, are to be invited to a little breakfast after the wedding. Won’t you write and tell us that engraved invitations are necessary so that my mother will see her mistake? She doesn’t seem to think I know.” 

I am sorry for your sake that I cannot say that the invitations must be engraved. At formal weddings they are usually engraved but there is not the least reason in the world why personal notes written, by your mother would not answer the purpose. Of course, the invitations should come from her and not from you and if she would rather write fifty notes in order to save the cost of the engraved invitations for some good war relief work, I think you should be content. 
I recall the case of a young friend of my own whose wedding invitations were written by her mother, although they were persons of really large fortune. They did it in this way because the young girl wanted to invite all her school and college friends rather than friends of her family whom she did not know and the notes were in keeping with the informality of the affair. 
The written notes, to be a success, should be well written, of course, and on white a paper of very good quality. Since they are to be thus informal it is better to word them informally— not using the third person—and of course they should be sent only to intimate friends of your own or your mother’s, or your fiance’s. – By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917


🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Thursday, December 15, 2022

Speed the Parting Guest

The question has arisen as to whether or not it is correct for a hostess to escort a gentleman guest to the door when there are no servants to attend to this duty. This is a problem which depends largely upon circumstances. If the man is a dinner guest, the host should escort him to the door. If he has come to pay an obligatory call, he should be received in the drawing or reception room and the hostess should take leave of him there without going to the door. If he is a young man making a friendly call upon a young woman, it is entirely optional whether or not she takes leave of him at the door. While it is not good form to go to the street door with every gentleman guest who calls, one should bear in mind that circumstances alter cases and that it is better to break a slight rule of etiquette than hurt the feelings of someone who is sensitive. Elderly men and old friends of the family should be accompanied to the street door– others may be accompanied to the drawing-room door or street door, as considered most appropriate. – Lillian Eichler
“Let us take a ceremonious leave, And loving farewell of our several friends.” —Shakespeare

When a guest in your house rises to leave it is not a good form to detain him. Either to urge him to stay or to detain him by extending the conversation, is not really considerate. If you accompany your friend to the door —and this you or one of your household should do whenever it is possible—do not start a new subject of conversation that would make it necessary for the caller to linger in the hall. If the call has been a formal call of courtesy between two women who are not very intimate, it is enough to say something like this: “It has been a great pleasure for me to see you, Mrs. Smith.” 

It is usual to shake hands with the guest as she says good-bye. To stand chatting in an open door after a guest has started to go is in bad form, even in the most simple of households. It is only courteous that you should see that your guest is seated so long as she is making her call, so if you detain her after she is risen, you are keeping her standing, and that is not considerate. If the call is one of condolence or congratulation it is courteous when saying good-bye to thank the caller for her kindness in calling. 

If the caller is an intimate friend it is courteous to ask her to call again, but to do this when the call is formal and simply one of the so called “call of courtesy,” would show ignorance of the laws of etiquette. For it would then not be the caller’s place to call again till after she had called on or entertained her. On saying good-bye at the close of a call it is never necessary to shake hands with any but your host and hostess. To shake hands with all members and guests of the family present is sometimes very awkward, especially when guests are departing from a party of any sort.– By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917


 🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

“Prinking” in Public is Bad Habit

Some women might like to have revived that custom of 200 years ago when beaux used to attend their women friends at their toilet table, but there is no charm or coquetry about seeing a woman wield a powder puff or lipstick in public. There was some artifice about the ladies of 200 years ago. For they had taken an hour at their dressing table to make ready for their dressing. Their maids had thoroughly made them, up and the hair had been labored with to produce the desired effect of charming disarray. Then, too, the men of those days left a renewed interest —and so, too, would the men of today if the custom were revived— in the fact that they were seeing something that all the world might not see—there was something a little risqué about chatting to a lady in her boudoir, even though it was sanctioned by conventional etiquette. 


“There is a time for some things and a time for all things; a time for great things, and a time for small things.”—Cervantes

Grandmother used to think its shockingly bad manners for a woman to put on her gloves after she had left her own front door. They should, not only be on, but all buttoned up by the time she started forth. What would the gentle old soul think if she could see the girls of this day who not only put on their gloves after they have left their homes, but adjust their veils by the nearest penny-in-the-slot chewing gum vendor, tuck up their stray locks with “invisible” hairpins taken from their handbags, and, anywhere or at any time that their little mirror in the top of their bags prompts them to do so, powder their noses and chins regardless of spectators? 

Of course, the young woman with what we call the finer instinct does not do these things, but the practice of “prinking” in public is by no means confined to the class of women who are usually not regarded as lacking in manners. I have seen many a woman, when the lights were partly down at the theater or the opera, surreptitiously pull a powder puff from her opera bag and, with a skilled stroke, efface any effect that the warmth may have had on her perfect makeup. One thing is certain and that is that no man ever enjoys seeing women of his acquaintance perform these little rites of the toilet table in public. 

Some women might like to have revived that custom of 200 years ago when beaux used to attend their women friends at their toilet table, but there is no charm or coquetry about seeing a woman wield a powder puff or lipstick in public. There was some artifice about the ladies of 200 years ago. For they had taken an hour at their dressing table to make ready for their dressing. Their maids had thoroughly made them, up and the hair had been labored with to produce the desired effect of charming disarray. Then, too, the men of those days left a renewed interest —and so, too, would the men of today if the custom were revived— in the fact that they were seeing something that all the world might not see—there was something a little risqué about chatting to a lady in her boudoir, even though it was sanctioned by conventional etiquette. 

But with all the world and his wife looking on when your lady fair powders her nose or publicly acknowledges her own poor, health or lack of vitality by applying rouge to cheeks or carmine to lips, what can you—mere man—do but pray that some kind fate might give her the gift to see herself as others see her? – By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917


🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Tuesday, December 13, 2022

How to Acquire Manners

Though Lincoln was brought up in the simplest, rudest of homes, he possessed that innate courtesy and considerateness upon which all good manners are based. Though he may not have had good table manners when he first went out in the world, he did have that characteristic that is the basis of all good table manners —a desire not to offend those with whom he was brought in social contact. 

“Men are polished, through act and speech, each by each, 
As pebbles are smoothed on the rolling beach.” —Trowbridge

To attempt to appear well-bred when one has been brought up without breeding would be sheer affectation. Such is the opinion of some persons who regard good manners as the exclusive property of those who belong to families where social amenities are well established. And some persons go so far as to say that the person who has not been taught good manners in childhood never can appear well-bred, since good breeding is just what the word implies— good birth and good bringing up. This argument is refuted best by the many examples of men in public life in America, who have come from rude homes and have acquired almost faultless manners. 

To accuse Abraham Lincoln either of affectation or lack of loyalty for his simple childhood home would be absurd. To imagine that there was time or opportunity for “foolish manners” in that little backwoods cabin would also be a stretch of the imagination. And yet the mature Lincoln’s manners and good breeding were almost flawless; for no man could do the courteous thing more graciously than he, no man could put those with whom he associated more at ease in even the slightest transaction than he, and few men have ever been able by a word or gesture so thoroughly to bridge over a trying situation as did Lincoln. This is how it came about. 

Though Lincoln was brought up in the simplest, rudest of homes, he possessed that innate courtesy and considerateness upon which all good manners are based. Though he may not have had good table manners when he first went out in the world, he did have that characteristic that is the basis of all good table manners —a desire not to offend those with whom he was brought in social contact. 

The boorish self-made man feels that it is a matter of affectation to eat in any other manner than that to which he was accustomed in childhood. The man like Lincoln quickly notes the ways of the world and, lest the crude manners of the cabin might offend, he adopts the new. The young Lincoln might not have known the correct etiquette for introducing a man to a woman of his acquaintance, but he possessed that innate courtesy toward women that is the basis of all good manners between men and women. Because he had this, he learned quickly the world’s way of showing courtesy to women. 

Good manners are not only earmarks of good family and good rearing. We do not follow the laws of etiquette merely because we want others to think that we have been brought up with a certain amount of leisure and care that our parents have enjoyed prosperity and cultivation and that our ancestors were early colonists of the land. If that were the reason, we sought to be well bred, then it might be affectation. But etiquette is the system of conduct that has been built up, bit by bit, as the best means of carrying on social intercourse. 

The man who has been brought up among ill-mannered folk does not, on mingling with better bred persons, give up eating with his knife because he wants to delude them into thinking that he is an aristocrat, but because eating with the fork is most convenient and appropriate and if he did not do it, he would offend others and attract attention to his own peculiarities. – By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917



🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Monday, December 12, 2022

Wagers and Etiquette of the Sexes

If you felt that it was wrong for your daughter in college to stake a “batch” of fudge versus a pound of chocolates with her roommate’s brother as to the marks she was to receive at mid- year examinations or even theater tickets over the outcome of a basketball game between the “Freshs and the Sophs,” then the chances are that you would look with disfavor on your son when he staked a goodly share of his next month’s allowance on the next football game.

No Impropriety in Small Wagers

“That makes the good and bad of manners, namely what helps or hinders fellowship.” -Emerson

“Lay no wagers with a gentleman and have no philopenas with them,” cautions a “behavior book,” in wide circulation half a century ago. “In betting with a lady it is customary for a gentleman to pay whether he wins or loses. No delicate and refined female ever bets at all. It always reminds gentlemen of the race course or gambling table.

That many have been very good advice for women fifty years ago, when most women really wanted to be looked upon as “delicate and refined females,” but it would be as absurd for the girl of today to act upon that advice as to wear hoop skirts and to affect a modesty that made it appear indecorous to show more than the toe or at most the instep— beneath those encumbering petticoats.

Sensible and well bred girls of today feel that they have done nothing indescreet in laying small wagers. If they do object to it it is a matter of principle rather than of etiquette. No sane person would consider a girl as ill bred just because she stakes a pound of candy on the outcome of an election or a football game. 

Though the fairness and desirability of equal suffrage is still a moot question among many persons, there are few who lament the fact that the tendency in manners today is toward equality among the sexes. The same characteristic of betting that might make it in bad form for women would also make it in bad form for men. 

If you felt that it was wrong for your daughter in college to stake a “batch” of fudge versus a pound of chocolates with her roommate’s brother as to the marks she was to receive at mid- year examinations or even theater tickets over the outcome of a basketball game between the “Freshs and the Sophs,” then the chances are that you would look with disfavor on your son when he staked a goodly share of his next month’s allowance on the next football game.

The man nowadays who “pays whether he loses or not” is regarded as a poor sport, or at least rather old fashioned. A girl with spirit would never wish to lay a wager with that sort of old school gentleman and she might quite naturally be a little offended if, after he had fairly won a bet, he refused to accept the stake.

Needless to say the girl who bets in season and out and who habitually suggests laying wagers is tire-some and troublesome to her friends. And since, anything that binders the smooth running of friendship is an act of bad manners she is herself ill bred.

For the sake of Mrs. Grundy, may I add that the rule that limits the gifts a young woman may receive from a young man to flowers, books and candy and taboos any article of clothing, ought to be considered in connection with this question of wagers. It is really better— and any sensible girl will agree with me, I am sure —not to suggest such things as hats, silk stockings and gloves or other apparel as the stake for a bet with a man outside of her own family. 

A girl of independent spirit does not like to give any man the satisfaction— if indeed he takes any satisfacton in it— of feeling that he has assisted in the purchase of her wardrobe. That it seems to me is a matter of common sense and not of arbitrary etiquette.— By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917


🍽Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Sunday, December 11, 2022

Afternoon Tea Etiquette of 1917

A tea set for easy serving that is comprised of a set of 6 cups and saucers, spoons, a sugar bowl and a creamer on a stand.

“And while the bubbling and loud-hissing
Throws up a steamy column, and the cups 
That cheer but not inebriate, wait on each,
So let us welcome peaceful evening in.” — Cowper

A question that readers frequently ask is whether or not napkins should be served with afternoon tea. And the answer is: you may do as you choose. If you do serve napkins don't make the mistake of serving dinner napkins. 

Small napkins about twelve inches square are most appropriate. The Madeira napkins are suitable but rather expensive. Squares of white linen neatly hem- stitched and marked, perhaps, with an initial or monogram at the corner are less expensive for the hostess who has time for needlework.

A popular book on etiquette makes the statement that it is the fashion nowadays to drink weak tea. Perhaps so, though, personally, it seems as if the drinking of strong afternoon tea was a transgression of the question is sometimes raised as to whether it is “smarter to drink tea with milk, cream or lemon.” 

Readers also want to be informed as to the amount of sugar that good form the permits in sugaring tea. Concerning seems as if Commissioner Hoover had more to say than Dame Fashion and since it is our patriotic duty to give up unnecessary lavishness in sugar, I venture to say that during the period of the war one lump is the correct amount of sugar to use. 

If you wish less than a lump it is awkward to attempt to break or bite a lump in two. Rather put in in in in your cup and do not stir your tea with your spoon after you have gained the desired amount of sweetness. 

A complete tea service includes a pitcher of light cream or leman. There is no good or bad form about lemon or milk— it is simply a matter of individual taste.

Nowadays tea is usually brought in the drawing room or sitting room on a large tray on which the complete tea service is arranged. A muffin stand may be brought in also bearing wafers or bread and butter sandwiches or small cakes or crackers. Sometimes a tea wagon holding the entire service is rolled in from the kitchen or pantry instead.

If you have a satisfactory alcohol tea kettle it is very nice to have this on the tea tray with the kettle full of hot water and proceed to bring the water to a boil and then make the tea, taking the tea leaves from a small tea caddy on the tea tray. But it is just as well, and sometimes more convenient, to have a teapot of freshly made tea and a jug of boiling water brought in from the kitchen. 

If you have no maid it is a simple matter to bring in the tea tray for yourself and drink tea in your living room, and that is in much better form than to take afternoon tea in the dining room. —By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1917


🍽️Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Saturday, December 10, 2022

Incongruous Actions in Bad Taste

Not many days ago at a large military funeral the color bearer was chewing gum, and among those lined up on either side of the street to witness the impressive procession there were thousands who mentally commented on this little piece of bad taste.


“I wish you a little more taste.” — Alan Rene Le Sage

Lots of the little things we do that had better been left undone are not things that any authroity on so- called etiquette could reasonably call in bad form— but they are incongruous and inappropriate actions that possibly irritate other people just as much as actual breaks in etiquette. There are some people who though they have little opportunity to learn the habits of polite society through fortuitous gift of good taste, ever seem to make a break. And there are others, who though trained from their youth in the edicts of society, can never be counted on to avoid incongruities.

Not many days ago at a large military funeral the color bearer was chewing gum, and among those lined up on either side of the street to witness the impressive procession there were thousands who mentally commented on this little piece of bad taste. Now, as a matter of fact, so many Americans do chew gum on occasions that it can hardly be called a piece of bad manners. Aviators, swimmers, football player, soldiers on the march, mountain climbers for the most part, find great help in gum chewing, and some doubt the soldier who had a long march to take on a warm day with a heavy banner to carry reflected that he would lighten his task a ward off thirst if he went fortified with gum. But chewing gum on the gridiron or in the swimming tank 1s one thing and chewing gum on a solemn procession is another. It is one of the things of which a person with an, inherent sense of the fitness of things would, of course, never be guilty.

Americans as a rule have a rather remarkable endowment of this feeling for the fitness of things. Especially is this true of our women. A humble farmer's daughter can go from her rural home and grace the most formal European drawing room and show no less grace of manner than the Duchesses with whom she mingles. And many of the women who have made the most tactful hostesses of our White House and have been praised most lavishly by European visitors are those who have had no preparatory social training save that of some back-woods community and have come fortified simply with this native American sense of congruity.

To a certain extent this is something that one acquires as a natural endowment; but in a measure it can be acquired. If you would acquire it, then cultivate your powers of observation. Note what other people are doing and without, of course, blindly following them, bend your manners in minor matters to suit theirs. A desire to be distinctive and individual, at any cost almost always leads a person to lose his sense of the fitness of things. He consults only his own whims and personal comfort. He feels that he is relinquishing some of his inalienable rights as an American citizen if he yields his personal whim and habit. — By Mary Marshall Duffee, 1918


🍽️Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia

Friday, December 9, 2022

When Respect Grew for Manners

Erasmus of Rotterdam ~ The Father of Children's Etiquette Instructors … The bronze statue of Erasmus, in Rotterdam. Created by Hendrick de Keyser in 1622, it replaced a stone statue from 1557.


New Respectability For Manners; Scholars Tackle a Topic Long Thought Too Trivial for All but Fussbudgets


The subject of manners once seemed worthy of serious attention. The authors of the Talmud took up such topics as burping, yawning and bad breath. Erasmus wrote the 16th-century equivalent of a best seller on civility and Edmund Burke considered manners more important than laws.

But somewhere between the Renaissance and the late 20th century, the topic got a bad name. Manners came to be viewed as trivial, hypocritical and superficial. Heavy thinkers abandoned manners to the authors of etiquette books, with their fussing about finger bowls and the evils of blowing on soup.

Now an interest in the subject, which once preoccupied the middle classes, is back in vogue, and not just among politicians like Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani, who earlier this week went so far as to invoke Plato in his continuing quest to make New York City a more orderly, civil and, well, mannerly place.

Judith Rodin, the president of the University of Pennsylvania, has convened a 48-member national commission, made up heavily of academics, that is in the midst of a three-to-five-year study of what some believe is an explosion of incivility degrading the quality of public life.

At Johns Hopkins University, P. M. Forni, a professor of Italian literature and culture, has organized a wide-ranging project that includes a course on civility, manners and politeness. It also includes research on civility in schools and in health care, and efforts to encourage scholarly work in the field.

Last fall, the university offered the course not only to its own undergraduates but also to inmates of a maximum-security prison in Jessup, Md. Having spent the semester studying texts like Erving Goffman's, “Interaction Ritual,” both groups came together at the end to discuss what they had learned.

And next month, Johns Hopkins plans to hold a three-day, international symposium titled “Reassessing Civility: Forms and Values at the End of the Century,” with speakers ranging from historians who have written on manners to Judith Martin, the author of the Miss Manners columns and books.

“Manners were expelled from respectable scholarly thinking: ‘Who would be interested in a stupid thing like that?’” Ms. Martin said in a recent interview. “Never mind that the answers are Burke, Mill, Emerson, Aristotle, Cicero, Castiglione, Erasmus, Locke.”

There is indeed a long tradition of serious writing on manners, not the least of which were three centuries of “courtesy books” originally written to instruct young princes but later directed to the sons of the upper classes.

One of the best known of the genre was Erasmus’, “De Civilitate Morum Puerilium” (“On Civility in Boys”), first published in 1526, which went into more than 130 editions and covered everything from dental hygiene and the importance of clean fingernails at the dinner table to when and how to spit.

A wide-eyed look suggests stupidity, Erasmus advised. If mucus falls on the ground while blowing one’s nose with two fingers, step on it, fast. When offered a communal tankard, wipe your mouth first. If food sticks to your teeth, remove it (with a quill or a toothpick, not a knife).

“The whole idea of manners was linked to civilization,” said Richard L. Bushman, a Columbia University historian and the author of “The Refinement of America” (Alfred A. Knopf, 1992). “It would be listed right along with the growth of art, science and law as a sign that we were civilized.”

But that view changed, at least among scholars. Michael Curtin, a historian in Oakland, Calif., has traced the shift to the late-18th and early-19th centuries, when he believes the long association between manners and morals was irrevocably broken.

In an article published in the Journal of Modern History in September 1985, Mr. Curtin in particular blamed Lord Chesterfield's courtesy book, “Letters to His Son,” published in 1774, which Mr. Curtin said “appeared to represent manners at their most cynical, expedient and immoral light.” In the book, manners seemed to be entirely in the service of self-interest and self-aggrandizement rather than of any broader civic good.

At the same time, Mr. Curtin suggested, Romanticism helped doom the courtesy book. Cosmopolitan standards of civility became suspect. As he put it, the Romantic quest for deep and authentic feeling, uninhibited by propriety and social convention, was destructive of manners.

Others, including Mr. Bushman, trace the decline of serious attention to the subject to the rejection of the formality and triviality of late-Victorian manners. “We had to reduce it in scholarly importance, so we just cast it aside,” he said. “They were seen as something curious and quaint.”

But in 1978, a history of manners that was then 40 years old, “The Civilizing Process” (Blackwell) by Norbert Elias, was published in English for the first time. Many scholars say has since inspired new interest in manners and helped transform the way they are seen.

First published in German in the late 1930's, the book followed the evolution of manners in Western Europe since the Middle Ages. Mr. Elias, a sociologist and social historian, tracked what he described as a rising level of shame about bodily functions and restraint in public, and traced it to the development of the modern state.

The emergence of the state, with its monopoly on violence and the growing interdependence of its members, necessitated greater degrees of individual self-control, Mr. Elias suggested. People began to modify their approach to everything from eating and scratching to spitting and sex.

Tracing the Fork And the Spittoon

Mr. Elias tracked such things as the arrival of the fork at the end of the Middle Ages, which put distance between diner and dined upon; the increasing restrictions on the way knives were used, the introduction of the nightdress, the handkerchief, the chamber pot, the spittoon.

Since the book’s appearance in English, a number of scholars, many of them influenced by Mr. Elias, have published books that have tended to view manners as a source of power or political authority and as a reflection of larger tensions in developing societies.

“Elias opened the door to a new kind of cultural history,” John F. Kasson, a historian at the University of North Carolina, has written. That kind of history, he said, is “keenly attuned to changing standards of emotional expression, bodily control and personal interaction, and seeking to correlate these with larger changes in social structure.”

In his own book, “Rudeness and Civility” (The Noonday Press, 1990), an examination of manners in 19th-century urban America, Mr. Kasson challenges the idea that so-called improvements in manners necessarily represented an unalloyed good.

“I wish to stress how established codes of behavior have often served in unacknowledged ways as checks against a fully democratic order,” Mr. Kasson wrote, “and in support of special interests, institutions of privilege, and structures of domination.”

As an example, he cites the case of the Astor Place Opera House, built in New York City in the 1840’s to embody the latest standards of etiquette and refinement. The house was “aristocratized,” with open seating eliminated and red damask seats sold only by subscription.

To exclude women of dubious respectability, Mr. Kasson writes, women were admitted only in the company of men. Men were expected to comply with a strict dress code that included evening dress, a fresh vest and kid gloves — a calculated slap, Mr. Kasson says, at working- and lower-class men.

“To look at manners in the 19th century is to realize that so-called good manners were often at the expense of a lot of deference to a broadly speaking privileged middle class,” Mr. Kasson said in an interview. “If class is the dirty secret in American life, manners is a way we launder it.”

Mr. Kasson is hardly the only current scholar of manners who acknowledges a debt to Mr. Elias. Another is Nancy Bentley, an assistant professor of English at the University of Pennsylvania, who in 1995 published “The Ethnography of Manners” (Cambridge), an analysis of the fiction of Henry James and Edith Wharton.

“People like Elias say there is a doubleness about manners,” Ms. Bentley said recently. “They are really about how you get along in a group. At the same time, these acts of gentility are also codes that do reinscribe power in some ways, even if they make for more peaceful coexistence.”

Table manners, for example, thus become arbitrary codes. “Insiders know these codes,” Ms. Bentley said. “If you don't, you won't be recognized as an insider. It becomes a way that you can have a kind of identity and recognition and joining of power that outsiders aren't able to claim.”

Ms. Bentley's sister, Amy Bentley, a cultural historian and assistant professor in the department of nutrition and food studies at New York University, has studied table manners in some detail. In a recent interview, she said she shared the view that manners are about power.

“They're necessary, but the ways they’re devised and developed can be about distancing people from one another,” she said. “Who is at the head of the table, who is carving, who waits until they are spoken to — all those kinds of rules about gender, age and other things.

“So I'm not anti-manners,” she said. “Because manners are good. But the ways that they've been used or developed can show interesting things about what people were anxious about in the society and who they were anxious about.”

A correction was made on

March 5, 1998: An article in the Arts and Ideas pages on Saturday about recent scholarly interest in manners referred incorrectly to the role of P. M. Forni in starting the civility project at Johns Hopkins University. He was one organizer; he shared that role with Giulia Sissa, a classics professor. –By Janny Scott, NYT, 1998


 🍽️Etiquette Enthusiast, Maura J. Graber, is the Site Editor for the Etiquipedia© Etiquette Encyclopedia